When it comes to improving competency in construction, are we starting in the right place? Gaynor Tennant, founder and chair of the Offsite Alliance and co-founder of ReThink Construction, takes a look
We have spent years trying to improve competence across construction, introducing frameworks, qualifications and assessment processes so people can do their jobs properly. I wouldn’t dismiss any of it, particularly in an industry where getting things wrong can be devastating, but I’m increasingly convinced we’re starting in the wrong place.
We seem to have accepted that enough competent individuals will add up to a capable industry. Experience tells me otherwise. I regularly see businesses offering services well beyond their competence, sometimes without appreciating the risks.
At the other end of the scale, I see people so focused on the boundaries of their role that they no longer question what’s happening around them. They do exactly what’s required, often very well, without asking whether it contributes to the right outcome.
Both concern me, especially as we invest far more in individual competence than in the organisations and systems people work within.
When competence doesn’t translate into performance
We’ve all seen projects where the architect is qualified, the engineer experienced, the manufacturer knows its product and the contractor has delivered countless similar
schemes, yet things still go wrong. Designs ignore production constraints, components arrive in the wrong sequence and information gets lost between teams.
Each organisation and individual may be good at what they do but somewhere between them we’ve failed to build the collective capability to get the project right.
What follows is a familiar hunt for who should have done what, rather than asking why the system let it happen.
We need to turn this around and start with organisational capability, rather than assuming it will emerge from individual competence.
Building capability from the top down
Through our Building Capability programme with the Manufacturing Technology Centre and Innovate UK, we’ve spent three years examining the capabilities an industrialising industry needs. The work identified 443 capability statements, organised into nine capability clusters and 19 Future Occupational Profiles.
The picture looks very different when we start with what an organisation needs to be capable of, rather than with job titles. Capability clusters let us identify what successful delivery requires before considering the roles and competencies beneath it. Rather than creating a new profession every time technology changes, we can see how existing expertise should work together and where new capability is needed.
Systems integration is a good example: it sits across design, manufacturing, logistics and construction, yet rarely belongs to one discipline. Appointing an integrator doesn’t automatically give an organisation the processes, information management or collaborative working needed to make integration happen.
That capability has to sit within the organisation, supported by people who understand how their decisions affect the wider project.
An industry changing faster than its workforce system
Industrialised construction is already shaping how we deliver schools, hospitals, prisons, defence projects and homes, yet our education, training and competence infrastructure still reflects an industry of separate trades and professions working in sequence.
The government’s call for evidence on a new Strategy for the Built Environment Professions, Trades & Occupations is a real opportunity to address this, and it’s at the heart of our submission.
I’ve worked on competence frameworks for years and know their limits. We can define what an individual needs to know in extraordinary detail, but without understanding the organisational capability it supports, we’re only solving part of the problem.
At ReThink Construction, we’ve built on that Building Capability work to develop the Industrialisation Readiness Framework, examining whether organisations are ready for industrialisation: the systems, leadership, integration and processes that turn individual competence into consistent performance.
Changing the way we think about competence
My concern is that we become so focused on demonstrating competence that we lose sight of the goal. We need people who know their limits but are confident enough to question decisions and spot when something isn’t working, even outside their job description.
That judgement doesn’t come from assessment alone, and it won’t flourish where responsibilities are fragmented, information is poorly managed or people are discouraged from looking beyond their own discipline.
If the government’s workforce strategy is to make a real difference, it must look beyond skills shortages, training numbers and occupational standards to how we develop capability across the industry.
I’m not suggesting individual competence is any less important, or that we need more regulation. Competent people need capable organisations around them, and the way we educate, develop and assess our workforce should reflect that.
For too long we’ve asked whether individuals are competent, and not enough whether the organisations employing them can deliver what they promise.
If we want a more capable construction industry, that’s where I believe we need to start.












